Skip to content
Best California Home Insurance
← The Latest

Two Duplexes, One Wildfire, Different Starting Points

California's new smoke damage law gives surviving homes in a wildfire impact zone a head start. Here is what it leaves open, and what to ask your agent or broker meanwhile.

Smell is not a test.

Picture two landlords. You could be either one. Each of you owns a duplex that came through a wildfire without a scorched board, and each of you has two tenants asking the same thing: when is it safe to move back?

The two of you are alike in nearly every way. Same kind of building, same kind of policy, same worried phone calls. One difference. Your duplex sits in a ZIP code that falls within the fire perimeter, or partly within it. The other landlord's sits just outside that line.

Under a new California law, AB 1795, the Smoke Damage Recovery Act, that difference counts. State officials say it is the first set of science-based standards of its kind in the country, built for houses that survived a fire but took in smoke, ash or soot.

For the first landlord, the law begins with a presumption. If smoke, ash, soot or char is found in a surviving building inside the wildfire impact zone, the damage is assumed to have come from that fire. The insurance company can still try to show it did not. And the zone is defined by ZIP code, which is why the address carries so much weight.

Testing is the other big change. You used to be the one arranging and paying for it, often just to prove there was contamination. Under the law, the insurance company covers the sampling and testing required to restore a home and clear it for occupancy. Living expense benefits cannot be shut off until a qualifying home is restored and safe. You still pick your own restoration contractor, and adjusters on smoke claims must be trained.

Does the landlord outside the line get all of that? The presumption is written for the impact zone, so do not count on it. Whether any given home or claim qualifies turns on your policy and the facts, and nobody can promise you an answer from the outside.

Now, what does the law not cover yet? Quite a bit.

The state has not set contamination numbers. So the law cannot yet tell you how much ash in the attic is too much. It also arrives in stages: some provisions on January 1, 2027, the rest on January 1, 2028 and July 1, 2029. And it looks forward. Earlier fires are not reopened, and their claims follow the rules already in place.

Your tenants are in the picture too. A renters policy is one kind of residential property insurance, and the law applies to that whole category. They can ask their own agent or broker the same questions you ask yours.

So what do you do while the details get filled in? Read your policy now, while nothing is smoldering. Look for the smoke language, the living expense limits and who chooses the contractor. Then ask your agent or broker, "If my property survived but smelled of smoke, who documents the damage, and what would I owe up front?"

Get the answer in writing. It reads better in a quiet week.